Tags
#WPLongform, photography, river cruise, Three Gorges, Three Gorges Dam, travel, Yangtze River, Yangtze River cruise
1-3 June 2018.
We were warned that the Yangtze River is very industrialised and not to expect lush scenery or pretty natural landscapes. I forgot of course. I did a three-night Nile cruise with Intrepid Travel a couple of years back and it was one of the highlights of all my travels. I was in a kind of bliss for the whole time. There was beautiful scenery and the river was alive with farmers working on the banks, and people doing laundry and swimming in the river, and abundant birdlife, and there were stops to see glorious antiquities. Every day was a revelation. The Yangtze was not that.
Despite having read the trip notes, and despite telling myself to enjoy what IS, the Yangtze Cruise, for various reasons, was not overall a wonderful experience for me. I’m pretty sure it was for the others in my group, so you shouldn’t let my story count for too much. And it’s never a good idea to compare one experience with another, but oh so difficult not to. That would require me to have no opinions. Plus, and I think this is very important, the Nile cruise was only about half full, and at every stop there were very few tourists; not many people travel to Egypt these days. On the other hand the cruise boat on the Yangtze is fully booked with Chinese tourists, and the cruise is designed to cater to them. I’m travelling with Peter, our Chinese guide, and seven others on a three-week Intrepid tour of China. We are the only westerners on board.
As I look back at it now, reading my notes and going through my photos I wonder what my problem was. You probably will too.
We board in Chongqing, one of China’s five biggest cities and a major Yangtze River port. We’re offered a cabin upgrade if we buy a tour of the small gorges and something advertised as a “live-action” performance called War of the Three Kingdoms, or alternatively Changjiang Three Gorges Large-scaled Landscape Live-action Show. I have no idea what it is but the trailer playing on the screens in the lobby of the boat
sure makes it look interesting. So I buy both and get my upgrade. We’re also encouraged, again for a price, to upgrade to the VIP dining room. We all choose not to.
I’m assigned to a two-bed cabin with a small balcony and bathroom that I share with a Chinese woman. She speaks no English and I no Chinese so we quietly accommodate each other and go our own way.
It’s the first night of the cruise! I’m excited and full of expectation, and uplifted by the lights of this enormous city as we slowly pull away from the dock and head out into the black darkness.
Eventually we all go to our cabins and settle in for the night. I don’t sleep well. The bed is hard and I can feel the coils of the mattress poking through. In the middle of the night I find a spare quilt in the cupboard, double it in two, and lay it on the bed. That helps.
OMG I’ve turned into a princess! When did that happen?
Also there is a speaker in the ceiling. From my notes:
There are constant announcements in Chinese and English. It’s time to wake up (at about 6.30), it’s time for breakfast (7am), it’s time now to meet for the shore excursion, now the second call for the shore excursion, now the third call for the shore excursion. I’d like to throw a brick at it. It is so loud it sounds like someone shouting at me. I found Mary who is the cruise staff assigned to take care of us foreigners because I couldn’t turn down the volume in my cabin. After much back and forth, and checking with my roommate, she agreed to disconnect it. Yay! Everything for the Chinese passengers is repeated 5 or 6 times. Mary said if they don’t say it that often they get complaints from people who say they didn’t hear it. Now she phones me if I need to be reminded of something.
It’s a grey rainy day,
the weather matching my mood as we cruise down the river past towns,
cities,
fishing boats,
and the occasional shanty.
The sky is grey, the water is brown, and I’m just a poor miserable sod who seems to have forgotten how to enjoy the moment. It’s not helped by spending part of the afternoon watching an old grainy movie (in English for us tiny band of westerners) of the river before the Three Gorges Dam was built. It’s so dreary I nearly fall asleep, so after about half an hour I go back to my cabin to complete the process.
The Yangtze is the world’s third longest river after the Nile and the Amazon, and is China’s lifeline. Starting in the northern Tibetan highlands, and passing through eighteen provinces, it eventually empties into the East China Sea at Shanghai. Flowing eastward the river covers a distance of nearly 6500 kilometres and divides China roughly into north and south.
Later that same afternoon we attend the Captain’s welcome in the dining room
in which all the main staff are briefly introduced. This is followed by a “play” performed by some of the young women who work on the boat. From my notes: Three women with red lipstick came on stage, two of them dressed as men with very stringy beards.
Something is narrated in Chinese over the audio system. It’s just a couple of sentences. Suddenly one of the “men” dropped to the floor dead, a couple more sentences of the story and the next “man” dropped dead, then the third person (I think a woman) suddenly dropped dead. A fourth actor came on stage to help the woman and within seconds he too dropped dead, then another man (this time it was really a man playing the part) came on stage and said a couple of sentences, and that was it. I have no idea what it was about but when the fourth person dropped dead in the space of less than five minutes I laughed, which was very rude of me since no one else laughed so I guess it wasn’t meant to be funny.
The food! The food is plentiful, varied and fabulous! Lunch -salad, rice, noodles, lots of green veg, several meat dishes, small very yummy seafood dumplings, dessert cakes and caramel flan.
And that night we dock (somewhere) and Thea and I go to the Changjiang Three Gorges Large-scaled Landscape Live-action Show, which is so spectacular I’ve run out of superlatives, so extraordinary it deserves its own post.
At about eleven the next morning we approach the first of the three gorges
and everyone is on deck for the show.
The landscape is more mountainous now
and we pass some small farms and villages.
Even so this river has been completely industrialised. There is no life left on it, and no heart. I never see a single bird.
The boat docks and we transfer to a smaller boat, which takes us into a tributary and deeper into the mountainous landscape. After ninety minutes we transfer to a motorised sampan
to travel for about forty minutes down even narrower waters,
passing fishermen
and a traditional boat that Peter said was probably put there by the government for the tourists.
The sampan boatman dresses in the traditional hat and cape of the early indigenous people of the area and shows us how they travelled the river before the invention of engines. Hans has a go,
and Bhakti poses for us in fine style.
But it’s not real. None of it is real. None of it is authentic. It’s a show put on for tourists and this is really brought home to me during the ninety minute boat ride that gets us to the sampans, and then back again to the cruise boat.
It should have been, it could have been, a gentle, even peaceful cruise down an ever-narrowing river between higher and higher cliffs; quite spectacular really despite the profoundly changed scenery due to the Three Gorges Dam, and despite that there are no longer any natural river banks. What we get is the high-pitched voice of a woman speaking, well really I should say shouting, pleading, harassing through speakers turned so loud that her already harsh voice is distorted. She is screaming at us the whole way there and back again. The speakers are at full volume and she talks in a monotone literally non-stop. Peter tells me she’s advertising things that are for sale on the boat. It seems impossible to get away from it. I try inside, I try out on deck. Eventually I find myself a small space outside the men’s toilet near the engines. The constant loud drone of the engines is preferable to the shrieking voice despite the smell of the toilet, the smell of diesel, and the smell of men smoking nearby.
Back on board the cruise boat I go down to the deck where I can get to the very front of the ship and sit there on the wide “bench” with my feet hanging over the edge, my arms draped over the railing, watching the water flow by, happy, at peace. Of course it doesn’t last. One of the crew sees me and tells me I can’t sit there because it’s too dangerous.
Looking back as evening falls I take this shot.
And looking back about a year later I see a beauty that I was unable to appreciate at the time.
That night is the Captain’s farewell dinner. It’s a banquet instead of the usual buffet, where dish after dish is brought to the table. Every dish is delicious and we are all groaning with full bellies and contentment. The meal is followed by a concert put on by the staff with the lovely Mary as MC.
There are several performances including a funny skit, a singer who has a good voice but is too shy to face us, and a game of musical chairs among volunteers from the audience. Tim is one of the volunteers, and nearly wins.
The highlight for me is all the girls. There are six of them. They work on the boat, probably in the kitchen or cleaning the rooms. In their spare time they dance. They entertain us first with a Latin flavoured dance, then Thai
ethnic Chinese
Indian
and ethnic Chinese again.
They are not polished, and you can see the concentration on their faces, but I find them sweet and delightful, an unexpected dessert.
We leave the boat the next morning for a tour of the Three Gorges Dam, the world’s largest ever construction scheme begun in 1971 and completed in 2009.
This is not my kind of attraction at all, but I must admit to some awe at the sheer size and audacity of it. It raised the river by 175 metres (574ft) submerging towns and villages, and is the world’s biggest electricity-generating plant.
It’s the end of the cruise. We take a bus, then another bus, to the railway station for our third overnight train on our long journey from Beijing to Hong Kong.
Next post: Changjiang Three Gorges Large-scaled Landscape Live-action Show: War of the Three Kingdoms – a cast of hundreds/thirty horses and skilled horsemen/laser and light shows/maidens descending from on high/rotating seating/and much more.
All words and images by Alison Louise Armstrong unless otherwise noted
© Alison Louise Armstrong and Adventures in Wonderland – a pilgrimage of the heart, 2010-2019.
We were very close to choose visiting China this year, but we went Peru instead🙂. Thank you for the insights of this cruise. I think I’ve heard that there are few stops along this trip, where one can visit some archeological sites, is it true?
All the best,
Christie
LikeLiked by 1 person
There were two stops. I chose not to go to the first (Jade Emperor Palace) because I’d been unwell the day before and needed a quiet morning (hence my extreme irritation with the loud speaker in my cabin). I’ve just reread the trip itinerary and discovered there was a tour to Baidi Town (archaeological site). I’m completely astonished, and puzzled, that I didn’t go to this. I have nothing about it in my notes or photos but from pictures online it definitely looks like a place I would have chosen to go to, so I have no idea what happened there.
China is *definitely* worth a visit. Some truly amazing things to do and see there.
Alison
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you, Alison. China is on our bucket list, it just got postponed. Amazing places for sure, I followed and enjoyed so much all your posts!
Best regards to you and Don,
Christie
LikeLiked by 1 person
Loved your narration…and on a lighter vein, I could almost hear those irritating high pitches announcements over the speakerphone!!! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks so much Vidur. Oh the endless announcements definitely created a special place in hell for me lol.
Alison
LikeLiked by 1 person
I so love your honesty, much preferrable to the ever-present ”everything is so glamorous” style. I think I would have been annoyed by the same things as you. Beautiful photos, as always 😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks so much TSMS. Part of the problem was there were things that I think were legitimately offensive – the speaker in the cabin, and the constant screeching of the saleswoman on the smaller boat. I’ve been on several other cruises of varying lengths and never was the peace in my cabin interrupted in such a way.
On the other hand I was just not happy in myself at the time, and I was expecting so much that it was bound to be a struggle for me. Oh well. Sometimes travel is not all we hope for as I’m sure you well know.
Alison
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes indeed
LikeLiked by 1 person
Glad you can look back and see some positives from the ‘cruise’. That said, I swear all Chinese mattresses are filled with rocks from the Himalayas.
LikeLiked by 1 person
There were some positives – despite the river being pretty much dead (not a single bird!) the scenery was pretty spectacular in the narrow canyons, and in places along the river. The food was some of the best of the whole trip. And the staff performance was very cute.
Alison
LikeLike
Well your photos are wonderful. I can relate to your no birds statement well. I saw maybe three birds total on The Hood Canal which shocked the beegeezus out of me. I assess the health of anywhere by the presence of birds and I am noticing less and less of them, which I guess coincides with the 30% reduction estimates for wild birds in North America. I have great respect for you not dismantling the speaker in your cabin. I would have on the first morning and put it back discretely so no one could tell. I am allergic to crowds so I feel your pain, acutely.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks so much Cindy. 30% reduction in estimates for wild NA birds! That is disturbing. I think if I’d had a brick there’s a possibility that I would have thrown it at the speaker in the cabin, and when the volume knob had no affect I knew for sure I needed help. Thank goodness for Mary!
Alison
LikeLike
I’ve just returned from a 12 day trip to China with Exodus. I looked at doing a longer trip with the Yangtze River Cruise, but this is not the first time I’ve read a less than positive review of it, and I’m very glad I didn’t do it after reading this. That said, the trip I did was amazing, I really liked China and we had a Chinese tour guide called Peter…! Probably the same guy.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think it was a good choice to skip the cruise, though some of my discontent was definitely just my mood at the time. I agree China is *amazing* and definitely worth a visit. I’m not sure but I think Peter works only for Intrepid, but I could be wrong. Perhaps he’s freelance.
Alison
LikeLike
I love the way you narrated the stories and appreciate the honesty. I could even imagine how the loudspeaker bang into my ears. Despite some dissatisfaction, I found that some views of your pictures are beautiful. I hope the reality is beautiful as it. Thanks for sharing this story, Alison.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks so much Nurul. Oh those loudspeakers in my cabin and on the smaller boat were a special kind of hell that’s for sure.
Some of the scenery was very beautiful and I’m glad I was able to capture some of that.
Alison
LikeLiked by 1 person
What an epic adventure. The scenery and views look absolutely fabulous but I don’t like the sound of the smaller boat trip with the forceful selling and loud commentary. No my idea of fun. The views all the way are fascinating though aren’t they, great post.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks Jonno. It was pretty epic, even if I was assaulted by the loudspeaker screaming. Some of the scenery was quite lovely, and the smaller gorges were pretty spectacular.
Alison
LikeLiked by 1 person
As Cindy says, and as always, you have some wonderful photos, Alison. But I’m thinking that I would have felt as uncomfortable as you on much of this trip. All the same, and also as others say – great to have such candid reportage.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks so much Tish. It was a bit hard to write this post. I knew I couldn’t pretend. I think there were things that really were egregious (all the screaming loudspeakers) but definitely a lot of my discontent was up to me. The others seemed to enjoy it, and I am pretty clear that I’d have had a better experience if I didn’t have the Nile cruise to compare it to.
Alison
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think we’ve all had a few cranky periods of time when it would be hard to appreciate most anything! The loudspeakers alone would have pushed me into a snit, and the gray weather and a stranger for a roommate would not help. I actually think you came across as pretty positive by the end, though!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks Lexie. I think my two biggest issues were the screaming voices through the loudspeakers (which I fixed in the cabin), and the comparison to the Nile cruise. I wasn’t actively thinking of the Nile cruise, but I know I went on this one thinking it would be similar and it paled in comparison in every way except the food. I did my best to appreciate what it was, but as you say we all have those times when it’s hard to appreciate anything.
Alison
LikeLiked by 1 person
I appreciate your honesty Alison. Not every travel experience can be great or meet our expectations. It is interesting though that we can look back at things with a fresh eye and appreciate some of the things we missed or took for granted in our grumpy moods (though I certainly too would have been grumpy with that loudspeaker). Despite your less than glowing review, your photos are superb (love the nigh shots) and I see some pretty nice scenery.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks so much Caroline. There *was* some pretty nice scenery. I do wish I’d been more open to it. I was quite surprised when I started going through my photos months later and could see how lovely it was in places. I kind of cheated myself a bit because I was expecting/hoping for something different.
Alison
LikeLiked by 1 person
As I think others said, the noise would have driven me up the wall, too. I would have been miserable because of that. The backstory I remember hearing years ago, of all the villages being flooded and people forced out of their homes, would have been hard to forget, being right there. It might cast a pall for me.
As for birds, my sister-in-law, who grew up in Shanghai, was amazed and delighted at wildlife she saw in the US – she couldn’t believe her eyes, she would squeal at a common deer or bird, and still does sometimes! It’s sad that wildlife has no or little place in the lives of so many millions of people. And yet, moments like the finale with the young women doing one dance after another – so sweet. And all the food being served in style, no doubt that was fun!
The photo under “…the occasional shanty” is great. All that stonework is really, really cool. I would want to stop there and inspect it. 🙂 The sampan photo with all the women – it’s a lovely moment you captured, as you often do so well. Thank you for the honest report, Alison. Travel has its ups and downs, and plenty of mixed bags. 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks so much Lynn. The food was fabulous, and the dancers so lovely – so some good things. I think the biggest obstacle to getting the most out of this cruise was me. It was so much the opposite of the Nile cruise where there was plenty of birdlife and human life on the river. This part of the Yangtze anyway is pretty much dead I think. I was definitely expecting wildlife of some kind, even if it was only flocks of birds.
Trust you to notice the stonework in such detail! 🙂 That is so you. You teach me to look at things differently. All I could see was that the natural banks of the river no longer exist which made me sad. And yes somewhere in the background was the thought of the displacement of all those people and the loss of their villages.
Alison
LikeLiked by 1 person
Looking forward to the next post – sounds larger than life! 😉
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s really amazing
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you so much.
Alison
LikeLike
When you travel a lot, it’s normal to hit a period of grouchiness and disillusionment. It’s good to share these experiences, especially nowadays in the era of social media. Everything is supposed to be so perfect. So when you find yourself in a less than ideal situation, it’s easy to blame yourself for not finding everything fabulous. The fact that the river is so devoid of life would have depressed the hell out of me.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yeah, I think you nailed it. The lack of life on the river, and the industrialization was completely disheartening, especially since I was hoping for so much more. The opposite would have had me so excited and enlivened. The food was great though!
Also I’m so puzzled that I have no record of the second scheduled stop (to some ancient ruins). I opted not to go to the first stop (needed a slow morning) but I googled the second stop and for sure it’s something I would have gone to, so I have no clue what happened there.
As for sugar-coating travel experiences – I just can’t.
Alison
LikeLiked by 1 person
Like you anything that has been set up just for tourists really ruins it. So it was on Peru’s floating islands when the women were singing ‘for he’s a jolly good fellow’. Why couldn’t they be singing a traditional song of their own?
Your photos look beautiful Alison but the lack of wildlife is concerning. Do you think you would have enjoyed it more if Don had been with you?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks so much Sue. Are you still in Jordan? If yes, thank you so much for taking the time to read this while you’re travelling! I do appreciate it.
Oh yes, I agree about Peru’s floating islands! We felt the same way although they weren’t singing “for he’s a jolly good fellow” (how awful!) but it was completely, and sadly, touristified 😦
And so it is with the Yangtze cruises though I must say that what has been done to the river is not the fault of the cruise lines, but rather a result of the Three Gorges Dam, and the industrialization along the river.
I would have probably enjoyed it more if Don had been with me. I’d have been more content in myself and then perhaps more open to appreciating it.
Alison
LikeLike
Hi Alison, Your storytelling and photos are terrific. You do a great job capturing interesting travel moments. I’m happy for you that you saw it all despite some of the major discomforts.
We did a cruise here in 2000 before all the villages were flooded and it was sad to see what soon would be covered up. I remember our guide saying, “First gorge, Aaaah!, Second gorge, Aah, Third gorge, Eh”. I didn’t agree but I thought that was funny. And I’d forgotten about the Sampans…that was very fun. They were still constructing the dam at that time and it was frightening to see the tiny figures suspended on the wall of the dam.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you so much Jane. I’m glad I saw it all too, though it’s certainly not on my list of “must return to” places. 🙂
It must have been wonderful to see it all before the villages were obliterated. I’d imagine there was a much more authentic feel to the river then, with the river being more alive.
I don’t think I even took any photos of the third “gorge”.
Alison
LikeLiked by 1 person
Funny about the third gorge, Alison. 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Pingback: War of the Three Kingdoms – like an action movie only live! | Adventures in Wonderland
When I read this, I remember how artificial everything was in China. Nothing authentic left. I saw parks ‘erected’ with fully grown trees in less that two months – trees were uprooted from different areas to be planted elsewhere… Gardeners started work at dawn to ensure not a single leaf was on a path by the time most people were awake… And as for the multitude of announcements… kind of typical because Chinese people are taught from an early age to obey instructions whilst initiative and original thought is discouraged. Thank goodness it is not that bad in Vietnam, but we do have an early morning siren to announce when people should get up and another one early afternoon to let everyone know nap-time has finished… Maybe not everyone has an alarm clock here; that’s a thought!!!
Lieve
LikeLiked by 1 person
In a way I’m glad to read this; to know it’s not just me feeling the lack of authenticity. I’m blown away by the ‘creation’ of the parks by moving full-grown trees! And so sad about how the people are regulated. I found the constant announcements truly painful, I who usually crave silence, especially when in a natural setting. I once had the boatman turn the extremely loud music off on a boat on a river in Turkey. The others in the boat were obviously relieved though no one else had said anything. Sometimes I think people are afraid of silence, which I also find sad.
Vietnam’s sirens would drive me nuts.
Alison
LikeLiked by 1 person
Alison, I read the opening paragraph and was excited because some of the people on my intrepid tour had just done the Egypt one and told me about the Nile cruise. I want to do that trip so bad! I loved Jordan so much!
as for the Yangtze, it looks lovely once you get in the mountains. Did you ever go to Tiger Leaping Gorge?
LikeLiked by 1 person
I do hope you get to Egypt! That whole tour was absolutely magic, especially the Nile cruise. Did you read my post about it? It was such a special time so it was hard for me to get into the Yangtze cruise, especially being without Don.
We also loved Jordan, especially Petra. Isn’t is magnificent!
We didn’t go as far west as Tiger Leaping Gorge. At the end of the cruise we headed south to Yangshuo – extraordinary scenery and so lovely to see some of rural China. Some posts about that coming up.
Alison
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks Alison! I would love to read your post on the Nile cruise. I am so behind on reading these days but will go back and check out all your Egypt posts. I am really wanting to do that trip!!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Alison, as always I appreciate your candid reflections and observations. I would much prefer someone give an honest account of their travels than to say that everything was rainbows and butterflies, and this proves the Yangtze cruise is not something I’d personally want to do, even if the food is fantastic. The loudspeakers in the rooms (plus that screaming saleswoman on the smaller boat ride in the Three Gorges) would have driven me insane! No doubt part of the problem was down to unmet expectations, but who could blame you for feeling that way after experiencing the magic of the Nile?
I’m astonished (and saddened) that you didn’t see a single bird during the cruise. That in itself speaks volumes about the health of the river, as do the denuded banks which suggest that part of the Yangtze is now one giant reservoir. I’ve always felt the Three Gorges Dam was a big mistake… the idea of forcing over a million people to relocate from their ancestral towns and villages, and the loss of not just arable land but also irreplaceable historic sites and cultural heritage feels so wrong to me.
LikeLiked by 1 person
There’s no doubt the cruise was a disappointment which was heightened by my experience on the magical Nile, but I also know that I would have been much happier if Don had been with me. I missed him terribly during that whole time I was traveling solo in Japan and China. And as far as I could tell the others in my group enjoyed the cruise well enough.
I am so saddened about the loss of life, livelihood, and traditional villages and historical sites, not to mention the wildlife, with the creation of the Three Gorges Dam. What a short-sighted travesty. I think you are right that this part of the river at least is one giant resevoir.
I heard recently that the Chinese used huge amounts of pesticide thus killing all the insects and are now having to pollinate by hand. Sometimes I think we are a profoundly unintelligent species.
Alison
LikeLiked by 2 people
…authenticity is refreshing…always leave seeing spaces I’ve not seen…and learning more 🤓 thanks for sharing your travels Alison ☺️
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks Hedy. China is a fascinating country and I’m enjoying the process of sharing my experience bit by bit – even the not so wonderful parts 😦
Alison
LikeLiked by 1 person
Pingback: The Great Wall That Wasn’t, and other tales from China | Adventures in Wonderland
Pingback: A Portrait of China – a photo essay | Adventures in Wonderland